This entry concerns a June 2017 article in the New York Times regarding the origins of the Erie Canal, which gave us pain because it repeats
misinformation that has been accepted since the late 1820s regarding Dewitt
Clinton’s importance in the project, and incredibly, omits mention of the man
who was truly the originator of the concept and at the forefront of the start
of its implementation, Gouverneur Morris.
As early as 1775, Morris had
articulated a vision of the future greatness of New York and the contribution
to be made by a canal from Lake Erie to the Hudson. He repeated this concept to
Simeon Dewitt, the New York surveyor general, in 1803 (after many years in
Europe, where Morris visited a number of canals); Dewitt, who gave Morris full
credit as the visionary of the Canal, wrote later that “I very naturally
opposed the intermediate hills and valleys, as insuperable obstacles. His
answer was, in substance, labor improbus
omnia vincit, and that the object would justify the labour and expense,
whatever that might be.” In 1808, a
canal commission was established, with Morris at its head –Simeon Dewitt and
Dewitt Clinton were also commissioners-- and Morris wrote all of its reports
until 1816, traveled with them to scout out routes, and proposed a feasible
means of financing it through loans from Europe after the federal government
refused to lend support (an effort he led in a trip to Congress). Morris also published anonymous essays in
support of the canal. When the War of
1812 came, however, the project was rejected by the legislature, probably to
some extent because of Morris’s known (and fierce) opposition to the War,
though Morris continued to publish pieces supporting the canal. When the war
ended, interest in it surged once more. By this time, Morris was frequently
ill, and though he drafted a last commission report, it was apparently modified
by fellow commissioners and his name omitted. In May 1816, six months before
his death, Morris wrote to a friend about the project that he had had “a
Presentiment that when it became popular I should no longer be trusted with the
Management.” He saw “with Concern that it is now, like every Thing else,
swallowed up in the Vortex of Party” but he had noted previously that he was
happy to have the credit given to “any person you please” as long as the canal
would come to pass.
The belief that Clinton was the
father of the canal seems to be due to an 1829 pamphlet compiled by
a devoted friend of the governor, after Clinton’s death. The pamphlet quoted
Simeon Dewitt’s comments about Morris, but also cited other contrary sources,
who claimed, falsely, that Morris had been a hindrance to the project, that his
proposals regarding financing had been rejected with horror, and that he had
abandoned the project out of pique. It also gave great credit to a man named
Jesse Hawley, a merchant in Genesee, who had published a number of essays advocating a canal from Erie to the Hudson in the local newspaper, the Genesee Messenger, from late 1807-1808. The essays were detailed and were later considered prescient because of their predictions about the best route, and discussions of the benefits of an Erie to Hudson canal. I take this opportunity to point out that I originally attributed these essays to Morris, whose flights of rhetoric about the future of New York State, and personal information about European canals, recorded during his time in Europe, seemed the only likely source. I believe I am wrong about this, though I am looking forward to hearing more from someone who is currently working on Mr. Hawley. In any event, the 1829 pamphlet asserted that these essays had inspired Clinton had been inspired to pursue the canal, but we have seen no evidence of this as of yet, for Mr. Hawley's name and pseudonym of "Hercules" don't appear in the materials we reviewed about the Canal, including Morris's diaries and correspondence, which is surprising, or in Clinton's diary of the Canal survey trip. In any event, many
historians, including the author of the Wedding of the Waters,
apparently rely on this questionable pamphlet to dismiss Morris with scorn.
Whether Hawley's essays were a factor or not, the verifiable truth of Morris’s
work for the canal can be seen in Morris’s essays and in his diaries, both with
respect to his visits to canals in Europe and his tireless efforts on behalf of
the project during the 1800s. The diaries appear in a new transcription
published by the University of Virginia Press. Of course others made major
contributions as the engineering planning and construction began; but for the
editors of his papers, there is no question that Morris has been shamefully
ignored for his enlightened foresight and selfless dedication to what is one of
America’s most extraordinary achievements.
Sincerely, etc.
I had the pleasure of interviewing you some years ago regarding Gouvenor Morris. I noted to a young friend of mine who lives in the Bonx the role of Morris at the Constitutional Convention in his opposition to the Three-Fifths Clause, in writing the Preamble, and in giving the eulogy for Alexander Hamilton. Last week he visited the grave site at St. Ann's and was shocked. He spent several hours there and spoke to those running the soup kitchen as well as the religious services.
ReplyDeleteHe was talking about not allowing the 200th anniversary of Morris' death go unrecognized, as it did last November. He said, "As long as we do it before November 6, 2017, we are technically within the band of commemoration."
Is it possible for you to perhaps talk with him? His name is Jose Vega, he is about to turn 19, and has been working with a group called the Foundation for the Revival of Classical Culture. His email is josevega3923@yahoo.com
Great Article Journal Paper Writing Services projects for cse JavaScript Training in Chennai JavaScript Training in Chennai Project Centers in Chennai
DeleteKing and McDonald's. They command the cheap food showcase for their specialty and they Cooperate Identity design
ReplyDeleteGreat survey, I'm sure you're getting a great response. รับพระเครื่อง
ReplyDelete"I value those posts and look advances to more on the off chance that they give me thing that I needs on blog posts.
ReplyDeletewonkologist
icomparestudy
campaignsite-hk
autoquicktrade
digitalimperative-bcgdv
kvtakeout
helpingyoufindyourplace"
Best Movers and Packers in India | Call Now 9911629433
ReplyDeleteBest Movers and Packers in india
Movers and Packers in india
Mover and Packers
Movers and Packers in india
Movers and Packers in near me
Best Movers and Packers
Movers and Packers in all over india
The stability and dependability of their performance have made them well known.for more infosee morevisit here
ReplyDeleteThe key to success is to make sure you use every minute to your advantage.see morefor more inforead more
ReplyDeleteFollow your dreams if you believe the Universe believes in you.see moreread moreclick here
ReplyDeleteI’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your website?포커게임
ReplyDeleteI’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your website?슬롯머신
ReplyDeleteI’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your website?릴게임
ReplyDeleteI’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your website?온라인카지노
ReplyDeleteI’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your website?호텔카지노
ReplyDeleteI’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this blog. Thanks, I’ll try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your website?스포츠토토
ReplyDeleteI have a numerous blogs that I'm as of late working on, and I have been at the his articls for such information that helpful me.visit here
ReplyDeleteWho continually looking on the web for storys that can oblige. There is clearly a different to comprehend.for more info
ReplyDeleteFollow your fantasies in the event that you accept the Universe trusts in you.click here
ReplyDeleteA person's mind cannot be diverted from observation, imagination, and relocating vital expectations ever imagined.visit this page
ReplyDeleteGive a decision of all around arranged images or possibly natural sliders.for more info
ReplyDeletehttp://www.thesoriameffect.com/2017/11/beauty-favorite-of-week.html?showComment=1636111099570#c7385869583493168987
ReplyDeleteIn some cases it won't be feasible to choose whether the glass needs a maintenance or a substitution.visit here
ReplyDeleteIf you have lower expectations you limit your disappointment.visit herevisit hereread more
ReplyDeleteBe okay with who you are. when anyperson create fears by your mind, don't let them control you.read hereright hereclick herethese detailsadditional info
ReplyDeleteFollow your dreams if you believe the Universe believes in you.check herelearn moreclick for sourcenavigate to this site
ReplyDeletehttp://www.thesoriameffect.com/2017/11/beauty-favorite-of-week.html?showComment=1627896202919#c2625618228842943423
ReplyDeletehttp://www.gouverneurmorrispapers.com/2017/06/gouverneur-morris-was-father-of-erie.html?showComment=1627896215830#c1821643174927936401
http://blog.audreypowers.com/2009/06/more-in-garden-with-sophia.html?showComment=1627896230489#c8855656148709816422
https://www.sugarmootz.com/2019/01/back-to-basics-voxbox-review.html?showComment=1627896242835#c6403518569981588690
https://www.glamandglossblog.com/2018/11/current-obsession-gemstone-silver.html?showComment=1627896508405#c9110671925339607174
Innovation can turn into the 'wings' that will permit the instructive world to fly farther and quicker than any time in recent memory.read heresee pagelook herefind more infoview it
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteActual, avoids pursues there who happiness was master produces nor expound truth because and procure you, circumstances has, exercise, it know fault trivial this procure.read heresee pagelook herefind more infoview it
ReplyDelete